50 Hotels In Fire Island

Search Availability of For Your Dates

Search Hotels

Showing all Hotels in Fire Island

Sort By:

Filter
Sort By

1. Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven

30.8 kms from city centre

# 1 hotel in Fire Island

8.7

(845 reviews)

Facilities: Bar, Wifi, Pets Allowed, Beach, Pool, Food, Shuttle Service

Hotel with 6 room options

$175 onwards

View Deal >

2. Holiday Inn - Long Island - ISLIP Arpt East, an IHG Hotel

22.0 kms from city centre

# 2 hotel in Fire Island

8.6

(910 reviews)

Facilities: Bar, Wifi, Food

Hotel with 7 room options

$117 onwards

View Deal >

3. 112 Motel

21.5 kms from city centre

# 3 hotel in Fire Island

8.6

(184 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Garden, Food

Hotel with 3 room options

$180 onwards

View Deal >

4. Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

8.2 kms from Sailors Haven

# 4 hotel in Fire Island

8.6

(113 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Pool

Hotel with 10 room options

$229 onwards

View Deal >

5. Homewood Suites By Hilton Ronkonkoma

18.6 kms from city centre

# 5 hotel in Fire Island

8.5

(190 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Beach, Pool, Food

Hotel with 8 room options

$196 onwards

View Deal >

6. Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale

25.0 kms from city centre

# 6 hotel in Fire Island

8.5

(127 reviews)

Facilities: Bar, Wifi, Garden, Food

Hotel with 9 room options

$209 onwards

View Deal >

7. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

8.4 kms from Sailors Haven

# 7 hotel in Fire Island

8.4

(272 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi

Hotel with 7 room options

$169 onwards

View Deal >

8. Marriott Melville Long Island

27.8 kms from city centre

# 8 hotel in Fire Island

8.3

(530 reviews)

Reviewers Mention: The Marriott Melville Long Island in New York received positive reviews fo (Read More)r its friendly and attentive staff, exceptional cleanliness, comfortable rooms, and delicious complimentary breakfast. Guests praised the safety of the area and the excellent service provided by the bartender, Nicole. The valet service and desk staff were also commended for their great assistance. However, some guests encountered issues with the wifi connectivity. Overall, the hotel was described as a nice, convenient, and enjoyable place to stay.

4 star hotel with 2 room options

$239 onwards

View Deal >

9. Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook-Long Island, an IHG Hotel

27.1 kms from city centre

# 9 hotel in Fire Island

8.3

(367 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Pool, Food

Hotel with 9 room options

$174 onwards

View Deal >

10. Hampton Inn Long Island/Commack

21.5 kms from city centre

# 10 hotel in Fire Island

8.3

(262 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pool

Hotel with 6 room options

$187 onwards

View Deal >

Filter by popular facilities

Swimming Pool (0) Free Wifi (0) Restaurant (0) Fitness Center (0) Spa and Wellness center (0)

11. Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport

15.7 kms from city centre

# 11 hotel in Fire Island

8.3

(256 reviews)

Facilities: Bar, Wifi, Pets Allowed, Food

Hotel with 6 room options

$159 onwards

View Deal >

12. Courtyard Long Island MacArthur Airport

18.7 kms from city centre

# 12 hotel in Fire Island

8.3

(183 reviews)

Facilities: Bar, Wifi, Pool, Food

Hotel with 2 room options

$169 onwards

View Deal >

13. TownePlace Suites Republic Airport Long Island Farmingdale

25.0 kms from city centre

# 13 hotel in Fire Island

8.3

(92 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Food

Hotel with 8 room options

$189 onwards

View Deal >

14. SpringHill Suites Long Island Brookhaven

24.4 kms from city centre

# 14 hotel in Fire Island

8.2

(342 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Beach, Food

Hotel with 4 room options

$119 onwards

View Deal >

15. Residence Inn Long Island Hauppauge/Islandia

19.8 kms from city centre

# 15 hotel in Fire Island

8.2

(47 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Pool

Hotel with 8 room options

$199 onwards

View Deal >

16. Hyatt Regency Long Island

18.6 kms from city centre

# 16 hotel in Fire Island

8.1

(636 reviews)

Facilities: Bar, Wifi, Beach, Pool, Food

5 star hotel with 9 room options

$167 onwards

View Deal >

17. Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven

22.3 kms from city centre

# 17 hotel in Fire Island

8.1

(429 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Beach, Pool, Garden

Hotel with 5 room options

$146 onwards

View Deal >

18. Fairfield by Marriott Medford Long Island

23.0 kms from city centre

# 18 hotel in Fire Island

8.1

(305 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Pool, Garden, Shuttle Service

Hotel with 2 room options

$139 onwards

View Deal >

19. Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adults Only

18.1 kms from city centre

# 19 hotel in Fire Island

7.9

(1011 reviews)

Facilities: Bar, Wifi, Food

Hotel with 4 room options

$143 onwards

View Deal >

20. Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia

18.1 kms from city centre

# 20 hotel in Fire Island

7.9

(515 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Pool, Concierge Service

Hotel with 5 room options

$140 onwards

View Deal >

21. Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville

20.3 kms from city centre

# 21 hotel in Fire Island

7.9

(212 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Pool

Hotel with 2 room options

$159 onwards

View Deal >

22. Clegg's Hotel

Ocean Beach

# 22 hotel in Fire Island

7.9

(37 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Beach, Concierge Service, Food

Hotel with 8 room options

$286 onwards

View Deal >

23. Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island, an IHG Hotel

18.9 kms from city centre

# 23 hotel in Fire Island

7.8

(406 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Pets Allowed, Pool, Food

Hotel with 9 room options

$164 onwards

View Deal >

24. Best Western Bar Harbour Inn

25.5 kms from city centre

# 24 hotel in Fire Island

7.3

(499 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar

Hotel with 8 room options

$159 onwards

View Deal >

25. Hilton Long Island/Huntington

26.9 kms from city centre

# 25 hotel in Fire Island

7.2

(820 reviews)

Facilities: Bar, Wifi, Spa, Beach, Pool, Concierge Service, Food

Hotel with 9 room options

$189 onwards

View Deal >

26. Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island

23.1 kms from city centre

# 26 hotel in Fire Island

7.8

(431 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar

Inn with 5 room options

$139 onwards

View Deal >

27. The Ocean Bay House

Fair Harbor 4.9 kms from Sailors Haven

# 27 hotel in Fire Island

9.8

(23 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Spa, Beach, Pool, Garden, Concierge Service, Food

4 star bed and breakfast with 9 room options

$405 onwards

View Deal >

28. Hollywood Motel

23.6 kms from city centre

# 28 hotel in Fire Island

6.7

(66 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Beach

4 star hotel with 4 room options

$150 onwards

View Deal >

29. La Quinta by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport

15.2 kms from city centre

# 29 hotel in Fire Island

6.4

(1031 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Food, Shuttle Service

Hotel with 7 room options

$112 onwards

View Deal >

30. Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport

15.7 kms from city centre

# 30 hotel in Fire Island

6.7

(351 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar

Inn with 5 room options

$119 onwards

View Deal >

31. Extended Stay America Suites - Long Island - Melville

27.0 kms from city centre

# 31 hotel in Fire Island

5.9

(348 reviews)

Reviewers Mention: Guests praised the well-maintained grounds and clean rooms at Extended Sta (Read More)y America Suites - Long Island - Melville. Amenities like cable TV, microwave, and refrigerator were appreciated. Some mentioned that pillows could be firmer. The staff was described as kind and hospitable, and the hotel was considered reasonably priced. While some noise from animals was noted, guests still found it to be a very nice place and would consider returning.

Hotel with 4 room options

$175 onwards

View Deal >

32. Commack Inn

25.0 kms from city centre

# 32 hotel in Fire Island

5.9

(49 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar, Food

4 star hotel with 6 room options

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

33. Red Roof Inn Copiague

21.7 kms from city centre

# 33 hotel in Fire Island

5.8

(312 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi

Hotel with 8 room options

$131 onwards

View Deal >

34. Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

20.3 kms from city centre

# 34 hotel in Fire Island

5.5

(473 reviews)

Facilities: Bar, Wifi, Pool, Concierge Service, Food

Hotel with 9 room options

$185 onwards

View Deal >

35. The Starwood Inn

15.5 kms from city centre

# 35 hotel in Fire Island

5.4

(34 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi

Hotel with 4 room options

$124 onwards

View Deal >

36. Relax Inn North Babylon

17.1 kms from city centre

# 36 hotel in Fire Island

5.6

(176 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi

Motel with only 1 room option

$116 onwards

View Deal >

37. South Bay Motel

20.7 kms from city centre

# 37 hotel in Fire Island

5.6

(67 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Bar

Motel with 3 room options

$130 onwards

View Deal >

38. Clarion Hotel & Conference Center

15.6 kms from city centre

# 38 hotel in Fire Island

4.4

(213 reviews)

Facilities: Bar, Wifi, Garden, Concierge Service, Food, Shuttle Service

Hotel with 16 room options

$99 onwards

View Deal >

39. Sea La Vie

Ocean Beach

# 39 hotel in Fire Island

7.5

(10 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Garden

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$334 onwards

View Deal >

40. JD COZYNEST LLC

30.3 kms from city centre

# 40 hotel in Fire Island

8.9

(7 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi

Guest house with only 1 room option

$108 onwards

View Deal >

41. Two bedroom, living/dining room

23.5 kms from city centre

# 41 hotel in Fire Island

7.7

(6 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Garden, Food

Apartment with only 1 room option

$140 onwards

View Deal >

42. Bay Shore Vacation Rental about 7 Mi to the Beach

16.9 kms from city centre

# 42 hotel in Fire Island

9.6

(5 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Spa

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$177 onwards

View Deal >

43. Surfside Retreat On Champlain Street

Ocean Bay Park 1.7 kms from Ocean Beach

# 43 hotel in Fire Island

8.6

(5 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed

$388 onwards

View Deal >

44. Bay Shore Vacation Rental with Shared Yard!

16.9 kms from city centre

# 44 hotel in Fire Island

9.8

(4 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi

Apartment with only 1 room option

$283 onwards

View Deal >

45. 26 Duneway

Ocean Beach

# 45 hotel in Fire Island

7.0

(4 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed, Children's Playground

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$766 onwards

View Deal >

46. Pura Vida

Ocean Bay Park 1.8 kms from Ocean Beach

# 46 hotel in Fire Island

5.5

(4 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed

Holiday home with only 1 room option

$713 onwards

View Deal >

47. Long Island Oasis

24.3 kms from city centre

# 47 hotel in Fire Island

9.7

(3 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Garden

Luxury tent with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

48. Huron Hideaway

Ocean Bay Park 1.4 kms from Ocean Beach

# 48 hotel in Fire Island

9.3

(3 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi

$601 onwards

View Deal >

49. Waterfront Home with Large Deck and Dock on Narrow Bay

28.1 kms from city centre

# 49 hotel in Fire Island

9.0

(3 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Beach

Holiday home with only 1 room option

Enter dates
to see price

View Deal >

50. The Surfcomber Condos

Ocean Bay Park 1.7 kms from Ocean Beach

# 50 hotel in Fire Island

8.3

(3 reviews)

Facilities: Wifi, Pets Allowed

Apartment with 3 room options

$193 onwards

View Deal >

View all Fire Island Hotels on

Top Hotel Collections In Fire Island

Hotels in Nearby Places

FAQs on Fire Island

How much does a hotel in Fire Island cost on an average?

On an average, it costs INR 212 per night to book a hotel in Fire Island. You will pay on average around INR 356 if you choose to stay in a 4-star hotel. A 5-star hotel in Fire Island will cost around INR 167

What are the best places to stay in Fire Island?

Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven, Holiday Inn - Long Island - ISLIP Arpt East, an IHG Hotel, 112 Motel are among the best hotels in Fire Island. If you are looking for hotels less than INR 212, then the best hotels are Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven, Holiday Inn - Long Island - ISLIP Arpt East, an IHG Hotel, 112 Motel