Montauk Harbor 600 m from Hither Hills State Park Campground
# 1 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.8 /10
(274 reviews)
Resort with 20 room options
$ 147
onwards
Montauk Harbor 600 m from Kirk Park Beach
# 2 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.6 /10
(1217 reviews)
Resort with 4 room options
$ 138
onwards
Hither Plains 1.4 kms from Hither Hills State Park Campground
# 3 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.4 /10
(178 reviews)
Resort with 59 room options
$ 158
onwards
Montauk Harbor 500 m from Gosman's Dock
# 4 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.7 /10
(1838 reviews)
5 star hotel with 12 room options
$ 142
onwards
Montauk Harbor 800 m from Hither Hills State Park Campground
# 5 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.5 /10
(392 reviews)
Resort with 4 room options
$ 169
onwards
Montauk Harbor 600 m from Kirk Park Beach
# 6 in Best Hotels In Montauk
9.0 /10
(198 reviews)
Resort with 4 room options
$ 120
onwards
Lake Montauk 1.0 kms from Gin Beach
# 7 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.3 /10
(176 reviews)
4 star resort with 10 room options
$ 306
onwards
Montauk Harbor 200 m from Gin Beach
# 8 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.0 /10
(360 reviews)
5 star hotel with 10 room options
$ 199
onwards
Montauk Harbor 400 m from Kirk Park Beach
# 9 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.7 /10
(138 reviews)
Resort with 30 room options
$ 165
onwards
Montauk Harbor 1.0 kms from Ditch Plains Beach
# 10 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.7 /10
(175 reviews)
4 star resort with 11 room options
$ 255
onwards
Montauk Harbor 500 m from Hither Hills State Park Campground
# 11 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.4 /10
(171 reviews)
Resort with 42 room options
$ 148
onwards
Montauk Harbor 0 m from Kirk Park Beach
# 12 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.3 /10
(82 reviews)
4 star resort with 8 room options
$ 205
onwards
Montauk Harbor 300 m from Kirk Park Beach
# 13 in Best Hotels In Montauk
7.9 /10
(124 reviews)
Resort with 15 room options
$ 120
onwards
Montauk Harbor 700 m from Kirk Park Beach
# 14 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.5 /10
(161 reviews)
Hotel with 11 room options
$ 200
onwards
Montauk Harbor 200 m from Gin Beach
# 15 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.6 /10
(649 reviews)
4 star hotel with 11 room options
$ 110
onwards
Montauk Harbor 300 m from Gin Beach
# 16 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.9 /10
(216 reviews)
Hotel with 8 room options
$ 102
onwards
Montauk Harbor 600 m from Ditch Plains Beach
# 17 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.3 /10
(69 reviews)
5 star hotel with 10 room options
$ 289
onwards
Montauk Harbor 2.6 kms from Hither Hills State Park
# 18 in Best Hotels In Montauk
7.9 /10
(196 reviews)
5 star resort with 31 room options
$ 513
onwards
29.3 kms from city centre
# 19 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.5 /10
(117 reviews)
4 star hotel with 9 room options
$ 188
onwards
Hither Plains 1.8 kms from Hither Hills State Park Campground
# 20 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.8 /10
(71 reviews)
Hotel with 30 room options
Enter dates
to see price
Montauk Harbor 300 m from Gin Beach
# 21 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.7 /10
(135 reviews)
Hotel with 28 room options
$ 209
onwards
Montauk Harbor 1000 m from Kirk Park Beach
# 22 in Best Hotels In Montauk
9.3 /10
(111 reviews)
Motel with 4 room options
$ 180
onwards
Montauk Harbor 600 m from Ditch Plains Beach
# 23 in Best Hotels In Montauk
8.0 /10
(242 reviews)
Motel with 28 room options
$ 117
onwards
Montauk Harbor 500 m from Kirk Park Beach
# 24 in Best Hotels In Montauk
7.6 /10
(69 reviews)
Motel with 12 room options
$ 128
onwards
Montauk Harbor 300 m from Navy Road
# 25 in Best Hotels In Montauk
7.6 /10
(104 reviews)
Hotel with 5 room options
Enter dates
to see price
Montauk Harbor 600 m from Ditch Plains Beach
# 26 in Best Hotels In Montauk
7.8 /10
(190 reviews)
Hotel with 6 room options
$ 119
onwards
Montauk Harbor 500 m from Gin Beach
# 27 in Best Hotels In Montauk
7.8 /10
(878 reviews)
Motel with 6 room options
$ 119
onwards
# 28 in Best Hotels In Montauk
# 29 in Best Hotels In Montauk
# 30 in Best Hotels In Montauk
# 31 in Best Hotels In Montauk
However, you can try some of these similar properties.
Montauk Harbor 500 m from Kirk Park Beach
9.0
(339 reviews)
Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Bar , Pool
Motel with 4 room options
$120
onwards
Montauk Harbor 700 m from Ditch Plains Beach
8.8
(5 reviews)
Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Bar , Pool , Food
Aparthotel with 3 room options
$500
onwards
Montauk Harbor 1.4 kms from Hither Hills State Park
Facilities: Parking , Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
Montauk Harbor 1.9 kms from Hither Hills State Park
Facilities: Parking , Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
Montauk Harbor 200 m from Ditch Plains Beach
Facilities: Parking , Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
Lake Montauk 1.8 kms from Ditch Plains Beach
Facilities: Parking , Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
Montauk Harbor 300 m from Ditch Plains Beach
8.0
(1 reviews)
Facilities: Parking , Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
Lake Montauk 900 m from Gin Beach
8.8
(42 reviews)
Facilities: Parking , Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
$500
onwards
Montauk Harbor 800 m from Gin Beach
Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Pool
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
Hither Plains 2.5 kms from Hither Hills State Park Campground
Facilities: Parking , Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
9.0
(2 reviews)
Facilities: Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
Amagansett 600 m from Main Beach
Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Pool
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
9.6
(22 reviews)
Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Bar , Food
5 star hotel with 8 room options
$495
onwards
Facilities: Parking , Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
$718
onwards
Facilities: Parking , Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
Montauk 2.8 kms from Sag Harbor
9.0
(1 reviews)
Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Pool
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
Facilities: Parking , Wifi , Pool
Holiday home with only 1 room option
$1,153
onwards
Facilities: Parking , Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
$945
onwards
Montauk 3.6 kms from Sag Harbor
Facilities: Parking , Wifi
Holiday home with only 1 room option
Enter dates
to see price
Compare package quotes from top travel agents
Compare upto 3 quotes for free